The pros and cons of being an older dadColoCRM2018-10-16T12:20:50-06:00
The pros and cons of being an older dad
June 17, 2018 By Nicole Spector
As a woman of a certain age (35) who is hoping to have children, I’m flooded with information, suggestions and unsolicited advice about what motherhood (in the biological sense) might look like for me. “You really need to start soon!” is the phrase I hear ad nauseum from presumably well-meaning family and friends.
My fiancé, Patrick is pushing 40 and just as eager to raise kids as me, but the subject doesn’t much come up for him. He may be asked if he wants to be a dad, but never does his “yes” lead to a bombardment of follow-up questions and a recitation of scientific tidbits. I’m not arguing that he should be put through this awkward line of interrogation (frankly, I think we should both be left alone unless we’re asking for input), but surely, it says a lot about our society that nobody ever reminds him that to an extent, the biological clock is ticking for him, too. Perhaps they just don’t know that the risks for aging men surrounding fertility and the health off their offspring; after all, until I started to do the research, I had only a vague idea of them.
Things can start to change after 40
As a woman, I can say that I’ve heard the phrase “your eggs become geriatric when you’re 35” maybe 50 times since I turned 30. Turns out, men have their own ages to be mindful of.
“It’s on a hockey stick shaped curve [of risks], just as it is with women, but with men the stick is a lot longer. The risks can start at 40 or maybe even 50 or 60 and then [risks] rapidly rise after 60,” says Dr. Paul Turek, a men’s health and fertility urologist.
Dr. Brian A. Levine, the founding partner and practice director of CCRM New York, board-certified in both reproductive endocrinology and infertility and obstetrics and gynecology targets 50 as the age where concerns about paternal aging may present themselves for men.
“Despite men making sperm from puberty to death at the same rate, some of the sperm parameters start to change as men turn 50,” he says. “In terms of the age-old question, how old is too old? We don’t know the answer to that. There are multiple factors, and it takes a lot to make a healthy child and the outcome is dependent on age of the mother, the father and the uterine environment. ”
Sperm is made throughout a man’s life, but the system can get rusty
Sperm is made new every three months, but when the system is aging there can be errors, explains Dr. Turek. “A thousand sperm per heartbeat [is produced], but in an older man it can be delivered with breaks. It’s like packing a vase and the factory is overheated and it doesn’t get packaged well. That’s what happens to DNA, and it can cause miscarriages and infertility.”
The problem here is that even with broken DNA, so to speak, a semen analysis (that you may get to test your fertility) can “look very normal,” says Dr. Turek. “With older women we know that most of the [problems] that can affect the offspring are chromosomal, leading to either miscarriages or terminations and, rarely, birth defects. But generally, this can all be detected, defined and diagnosed so we can make decisions about them. With men, you can’t screen for these errors in the DNA that cause mutations unless you know of them ahead of time, but they tend to be new.”
Uncommon diseases and neurological issues
These errors tend to “easily get through quality control system [of the uterine environment] without causing miscarriage and can cause debilitating diseases in offspring like hemophilia, dwarfism and progeria,” says Dr. Turek. “Some of these are not picked up natally but [present] as children get older or become adults. Sometimes with older men you’ll see a successful childbirth and even a healthy child and then the issues hit.”
In the latter case, we tend to see epigenetic changes among certain gene sets that shape neurologic function. “These are neither mutations nor chromosome issues, just marks on DNA,” clarifies Dr. Turek. “Women do throw off mutations, but men do it five to ten times higher. And they tend to be neurodevelopmental features.”
Dr. Turek pinpoints the following risks for men over 40 (with the risks sharpening as the decades pass):
2-fold increased risk of miscarriage
2-fold increased risk of pre-term birth
1.9-fold increased risk of pre-term death
25 percent increased risk of birth defects
2-fold increased risk of chromosomal abnormalities
10-fold increased risk of disease due to single gene mutations
5-fold increased risk of childhood and adult diseases (such as autism schizophrenia, bipolar and epilepsy)
“The good thing about being an older dad is that you tend to live longer, and you certainly have lots of young reasons to,” says Dr. Turek. “Your offspring also tends to live longer. We’re evolving a lot more rapidly and this system is trying to help us live longer, which is a plus for both the older dad and his child. So, it makes teleological sense that if you are healthy enough to reproduce at an older age, you’re good.”
The risks are there, but they’re relatively low
Dr. Turek has two kids, the second being born when he was in his late 40s. He had his concerns based on the known risks, but didn’t let them obstruct his desire to be a biological dad.
“I’m relatively risk-averse, but I looked at the big picture,” says Dr. Turek. “When thinking of that hockey stick analogy, I wasn’t in the steep part of the curve. I said to myself what is the chance a couple in America of any age will have a child with birth defects? The answer is a little over three percent. At most I was adding another three percent to that, but it just didn’t hit my radar as being risky.”
Make sure this is really what you want
Dr. Turek also became a dad at a slightly older age because he knew he wanted to, and this, according to licensed marriage and family therapist Allen Wagner may sound simple, but it takes some deep introspection, especially when you’re older and set in your ways.
“We can always learn, but a lot of people develop these habits and rigid routines and now becoming a parent will change those,” Wagner says. “People then must question whether they really want it, because it is really tough. There are a lot of pressures to become a father, and the worst reason to do it is to please someone else. I think a good reason to do it is because you want to share the things that excite you. Do it for the reason of understanding that your building something in another human being. The reasons have to be for you, though, and not to please your partner or your parents. Take ownership of this choice.”
Get everything checked out medically
And definitely get a checkup, particularly if you’re 50 or over.
“Get a proper evaluation. Talk to your doctor, to a reproductive endocrinologist and to your wife’s OBGYN,” says Dr. Levine. “Until you know what you’re dealing with, you can’t know; you may have perfect sperm at 50, but sperm abnormalities are silent. Unlike with say, menopause, there are no hot flashes. Additionally, what’s right for one person may not be right for the other [in terms of possible interventions]. But I can say that being a father is a wonderful thing. It’s my first and favorite job.”